House RegretsThe house you didn’t buy.

The index-fund rebuttal

Waterbury-Shelton, CT, 1988: home equity versus the same initial down payment invested in a fund.

$60,000 as a down payment$767,976 equity$60,000 in an S&P 500 index fund$3.66MHigher asset valuethe index fund

This compares asset values, not the total cost or return of buying versus renting. The home equity reflects mortgage principal paid after the down payment, but the fund starts with only that down payment. Mortgage payments, rent, taxes, insurance, maintenance and transaction costs are not netted against each other, and any ongoing cash-flow difference is not invested.

Take the same $60,000 in 1988. Route one: 20% down on a $300,000 Waterbury-Shelton, CT house, thirty-year loan at that year’s average rate. Route two: an S&P 500 index fund (the TSP C Fund), dividends reinvested.

Route one is worth about $767,976 of equity today. Route two was worth about $3.66M at the end of October 2026, the latest month the fund has reported at tsp.gov. The fund has the higher asset value in this example. The figures alone do not establish which route left a household better off after its ongoing costs.

The calculator puts the same index-fund line beside every metro’s numbers for any purchase year from 1988 on, so you can test your own year against it.

Check 1988 Waterbury-Shelton, CT yourself

House figures are estimates for the whole metro market, from the FHFA index. Not financial advice.